It's not so much the exercise itself that bothers me - they're actually a decent way to build some upper body strength. It's the name that's irritating. Why must it be girl push-ups? (Now, I realize they are occasionally referred to as "modified push-ups", but "girl push-ups" seems to be much more common. It has a particular ring to it that sticks in your mind.) Just the name itself places an entire gender into a box of "weaker than men". This may generally be true from a purely physical standpoint, but it's essentially stereotyping. We wouldn't go around declaring all Germans to be racist or all blonds to be dumb, so why is it perfectly acceptable to imply that one gender is far weaker than the other?
When you Google "modified push-ups", the images are almost exclusively of women |
Why was it so shocking that a female could do push-ups? What does that say about our society?
This is not just a one-way path of gender bias, however. If a man can only do "girl push-ups" he's considered lesser than those who can do full push-ups. That's not fair either. A person's value, regardless of their gender, should not be "measured in physical courage" (Ehrlich 571).
We human beings are comprised of so much more than flesh and bone, and we should be valued according to traits that reflect our complexity. -MC
Side note: The paper towel company Brawny recently released ads with the slogan "#strengthhasnogender". We are making steps towards overlooking physical strength!
The new ads depict women in the familiar red Brawny flannel |
I really like how you pointed out "girl push-ups" and how it makes us associate a lack of strength with being a girl. I also like how you incorporated the Brawny ad at the end; I hadn't seen that before.
ReplyDeleteMichelle, this was a fantastic piece! You make amazing points about stereotyping. It's definitely not the first time Iv'e seen guys being shocked over an athletic women. Along with your mention of "girl push-ups" the phrase "throw like a girl" falls right in line with your points. Great post!
ReplyDeleteMichelle, this post was really good! I really liked how you addressed both sides to your argument, helping to make yours that much more compelling. I also liked your personal anecdote about the time your were at the gym and there was a guy who was surprised to see you do push-ups. This is a great post, nice job.
ReplyDelete