Sunday, October 16, 2016

Où est Ma Chatte?

     The phrase "Où est ma chatte" is French for "where is my cat?" In Alice in Wonderland, Alice offends the small mouse she is talking to when she asks him that question. In a sense, the quote ties into the allegorical graphic novel Maus. In the two volumes, Art Spiegelman anthropomorphizes mice as the Jews and cats as the Germans. Just as in real life, the German cats terrorize the Jewish mice, effectively making their lives a living hell.
     Maus follows the story of Art Spiegelman and how he learns about his father Vladek's horrific but amazing survival as a Jew during World War II. It is a story within a story, a piece of meta-nonfiction. As readers, we immediately sympathize for Vladek and his bitter story of survival. However, after the war, it is evident how hypocritical Vladek truly is.
     As a victim of the cruelties of the Holocaust, he knows firsthand how destructive racism can be. Even so, when he, Art, and Françoise encounter a homeless colored man, Vladek protests his son and daughter-in-law's kindness to the man. He even goes so far as to say that Jews are far more superior to blacks.



     In an essence, Vladek's time as a victim of the war turns him into a Nazi of some sort. He believes his own race is better than others. It is darkly ironic, considering that this was the Nazi mentality that caused so much death to the Jews in the first place.
     So, as much as the war may have made Vladek stronger, it also shaped him into a more hateful, racist person. 
     You may think that I've put too much thought into analyzing one page of some random graphic novel. But, if there's one thing I've learned in my life it is that graphic novels can carry so much more weight than picture-less novels. Maus, in conjunction with Alison Bechdel's memoir Fun Home, are the two graphic novels that have changed my opinion on books with pictures forever. -MC

2 comments:

  1. I was also surprised by the parallelism between the Nazis and Vladek that is constantly shown in the book. Similar to what you said about hypocrisy in Vladek's racism despite that being the reason he had to go through the Holocaust, I thought it was sad that people made a social hiarchy even in Auschwitz. For instance, some had better jobs then others, and some even had a bit of influence there like the Kapo.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Michelle,
    Like you and Yunsoo, I was surprised at how honest Art really is in depicting him and his father. I believe that by doing so, he wanted to show how easy it can be to be hateful and hypocritical. Sometimes, when reading about the Holocaust, it can seem incomprehensible to us that the Nazis could've been so cruel. I know that many times while reading Maus, I asked myself how people could be so awful to one another. However, as various situations in the book portray, prejudice and hatred is present in every single person, and when ignited, has the potential to cause horrors like the Holocaust. Thank you for this post, I look forward to future ones :)

    ReplyDelete